Blog

When people first ask me about Laojia and Xinjia, they usually expect a simple answer. Old Frame versus New Frame. One is older, one is newer, and maybe Xinjia has a few extra movements. Technically, there’s some truth hiding in there, but it doesn’t come close to explaining what the difference feels like when you actually practice both.

For me, Laojia was much easier to enter. I could practice it in a somewhat higher stance, slow the movements down, and spend time figuring out where my feet, waist, and hands were supposed to go without every movement demanding everything from me at once. There was fajin, there was silk-reeling work, and there was certainly plenty to learn, but those qualities didn’t have to be pushed to their highest level just to get through the form.

Xinjia was another story. Once I really began working with it, I understood why people often spend years building their Laojia before taking New Frame seriously. The stances could become lower and more compact, the waist and dantian rotations felt more complicated, the spiraling became smaller and denser, and explosive releases appeared much more frequently. If Laojia gave me room to learn the language, Xinjia expected me to start having a fairly complicated conversation. That’s still the simplest way I explain the difference. Laojia gives you the foundation. Xinjia asks what you can actually do with that foundation.

First, “Old” and “New” Aren’t Quite as Simple as They Sound

The names can create trouble before we even get into the training. Laojia literally means “Old Frame,” while Xinjia means “New Frame,” so it’s natural to assume there was one old form and then somebody simply invented a newer replacement. Chen Style history is messier than that, and different branches don’t all tell the story in exactly the same way.

Within the widely practiced Chenjiagou Large Frame tradition, Laojia is associated with the teaching transmitted through Chen Changxing, while Xinjia is associated with the later methods of Chen Fake and, especially in its subsequent transmission, his son Chen Zhaokui. Chen Fake was born in 1887, went to Beijing in 1928, and remained one of the central figures in the twentieth-century spread of Chen family Tai Chi until his death in 1957.

The terminology itself became especially common much later. Chen Zhaokui returned to Chenjiagou in the 1970s and taught methods that differed visibly from what many students there had previously learned through Chen Zhaopei. Practitioners began distinguishing the familiar material as Laojia and the material associated with Chen Zhaokui as Xinjia. That’s worth remembering because Tai Chi history has a habit of becoming much cleaner after it gets repeated online for twenty years than it probably was while people were actually living it.

The Numbers: 74 Movements Versus 83 Is Only the Beginning

One obvious numerical difference is the length of the forms. In one commonly used Chenjiagou counting system, Laojia Yilu contains 74 postures, while Xinjia Yilu contains 83. Xinjia’s second routine is commonly counted at around 71 movements. Movement counts can vary slightly by lineage because teachers sometimes count transitions differently, so I wouldn’t start an argument over whether somebody says 74, 75, or another nearby number.

Those extra nine counted postures in Xinjia Yilu don’t really tell you how much more complicated the form can feel. On paper, 74 versus 83 doesn’t sound like a huge jump. In the body, the difference can be considerable because Xinjia tends to place more visible emphasis on smaller circles, wrist rotation, folding through the chest and waist, turning through the dantian, qinna expression, and repeated fajin.

That’s the part I couldn’t appreciate just by watching it. When I first saw Xinjia, some movements looked like more elaborate versions of things I already knew. Once I tried to do those movements properly, I realized the extra circles weren’t decoration. The waist, kua, chest, back, hands, and feet had to coordinate on a smaller scale, and the timing became much less forgiving.

Why Laojia Felt Like the Right Introductory Form for Me

I still consider Laojia the better introductory form for the way I learned Chen Style. I don’t mean “easy” in the sense that you can master it quickly. You could spend the rest of your life refining Laojia and continue finding mistakes. What I mean is that the entry requirements feel lower. You can begin learning the structure without needing advanced fajin or tiny, highly developed spirals from day one.

When I started with Laojia, I could keep my stance relatively high. That mattered. Instead of fighting my own thighs through every posture, I could pay attention to weight distribution, the kua, the waist, and where the movement was actually coming from. As my legs improved and my body opened, I could gradually lower the stance instead of forcing myself into something my structure wasn’t ready to support.

I also felt that silk-reeling energy was easier to approach because the circles were generally larger and less crowded with secondary details. I want to be careful about how I say that. Laojia doesn’t have less silk-reeling principle. Silk reeling runs throughout Chen Style. What felt different to me was that Laojia required a less complicated expression of it at the beginning. I could learn the large road before worrying about every little side street.

The same was true with fajin. Laojia Yilu contains power releases, but much of the routine gives you time to work through slower and softer movement. That gives a beginner room to establish posture and coordination before trying to make every movement explosive. Personally, that breathing room helped me much more than jumping immediately into something that looked advanced.

Laojia Is Easier to Start, Not Easy to Master

There’s an important distinction here. Calling Laojia easier than Xinjia can accidentally make it sound basic or shallow. It isn’t. Laojia is one of those forms where you learn the choreography and briefly feel proud of yourself, only to discover that memorizing the sequence was probably the easiest part.

Chen Fake is reported to have described Tai Chi learning in three stages: “first to learn the correct moves, then to practice often, and finally understand the details.” That description fits my experience with Laojia surprisingly well. Learning where the hands and feet go isn’t the end. It’s really just the admission ticket.

After I knew a movement well enough that I wasn’t worrying about what came next, different questions started showing up. Was my waist really leading? Was I opening the kua or merely bending my knee? Was my arm connected to the torso, or was I drawing a convincing circle with the arm alone? Could I remain relaxed while keeping structure? Could I issue power without winding up first? Those questions can keep someone busy for years.

Chen Xiaoxing once gave a demanding example of how traditional practitioners thought about repetition. He described fitting roughly 10 repetitions of the form into about two hours. If somebody did that every day for 365 days, that would come to around 3,650 repetitions in one year. The important point wasn’t that 3,650 is some magical number. It was that gongfu comes from accumulated repetition and time, not from collecting another form every few months.

Xinjia Felt Like Someone Turned Up the Resolution

The first time I seriously worked on Xinjia, it didn’t feel like starting over. It felt more like somebody had taken movements I already knew and suddenly increased the resolution. The large circle was still there, but now smaller circles appeared inside it. The waist movement I thought I understood became more detailed. The wrists rotated more clearly, while the chest and back opened and folded in ways I had previously treated almost as background movement.

The dantian rotation also became harder to ignore. If I tried to fake those details by moving my arms more, the form immediately became messy. That was one of the useful things Xinjia exposed for me. More visible complexity doesn’t mean you’re supposed to manufacture more external motion. The movement still has to come from the center and remain connected.

Chen Xiaoxing has described New Frame using similar differences, including smaller circles, greater wrist turning, more visible chest-and-waist folding, clearer waist and dantian rotation, more qinna expression, and more fajin. That description makes sense once you’ve practiced both forms because the difference isn’t merely how many movements you remember. The whole texture of the movement changes.

That’s why I don’t think of Xinjia as “Laojia but cooler.” It’s very easy to make Xinjia look busier without making it better. Add another waist movement here, roll the shoulder there, spin the wrist dramatically, and suddenly you have something complicated-looking that has lost the connection through the center.

Smaller Spirals Are Harder Than Bigger Spirals

Big movements are forgiving. If I’m learning a broad spiral through the arm and torso, I have time and space to feel where everything is going. The hand travels farther, the waist turn is easier to recognize, and mistakes are relatively easy to identify. Shrink that same idea and everything becomes fussier.

In Xinjia, those smaller circles still have to remain connected to the whole body. The hand shouldn’t independently draw a tiny spiral just because there’s supposed to be one. The spiral has to come out of coordinated rotation through the body. That sounds obvious when you say it, but doing it without turning the movement into a pile of separate tricks is much harder.

Chen Changxing is traditionally associated with the line, “Keep spiraling and never let go.” I like that phrase because it reminds me the spiral isn’t supposed to appear only when the hand happens to draw a visible circle. It’s part of how force changes and travels through the body.

This is one area where years of Laojia made Xinjia more understandable for me. Without the larger spiraling structure I learned in Laojia, I think I would’ve copied the visible Xinjia motions while missing much of what was supposed to be happening underneath them.

The Stance Difference Was Impossible for My Legs to Ignore

The difference in stance was another thing I noticed immediately. I learned Laojia in a way that allowed a relatively higher posture in the beginning. As the legs became stronger, the stance could gradually become lower, but I didn’t have to prove anything on the first day.

With Xinjia, I found myself spending much more time in lower and more compact positions. The transitions could become quicker, and the changes through the kua felt more demanding. That combination of lower posture, smaller circles, and stronger changes in direction made Xinjia much more physically demanding for me than simply doing another nine movements.

This doesn’t mean every Xinjia practitioner has to sit ridiculously low. Body type, age, knees, training purpose, and teacher all matter. I’ve learned not to worship low stances just because they look impressive. A deep stance with poor knee alignment isn’t advanced Tai Chi. It’s mostly a good way to have an unpleasant conversation with your knees tomorrow morning.

Fajin Is Where Xinjia Really Changes the Feeling

The explosive quality is probably the most obvious difference for me. Laojia Yilu gave me plenty of opportunities to work on power, but it didn’t constantly demand visible fajin. There was more time to move softly, connect the body, work through larger spirals, and let the rhythm breathe.

Xinjia feels much less shy about asking for power. There are more explosive moments, more sudden releases, and more places where the form seems to ask whether your body is actually connected. Historically, this also makes sense in relation to Chen Fake’s period teaching in Beijing beginning in 1928, where many students already had substantial martial arts experience and were interested in applications, qinna, spiraling mechanics, and power.

In my own practice, this was where Xinjia exposed bad habits brutally quickly. If the fajin came mostly from my arm, it felt wrong. If I tightened before releasing, the movement felt heavy instead of explosive. If I dropped into a low stance but lost the kua, I was doing a lot of work without producing very much result.

When it worked better, though, the feeling changed. Power didn’t seem like something I was adding at the end of the movement. It felt more like something the movement had been organizing all along.

Why I Think Xinjia Usually Makes More Sense After Years of Laojia

In the training path I’m familiar with, Xinjia isn’t something I’d rush into after a few months of Laojia. I would rather spend years developing the legs, waist, coordination, silk-reeling mechanics, relaxation, and basic fajin before expecting Xinjia to look or feel right.

That isn’t a universal Chen Style rule, and I think that distinction is important. Chenjiagou traditions commonly teach Laojia first, while some Beijing traditions associated with Chen Fake and Chen Zhaokui teach Xinjia much earlier. Both approaches exist, and I wouldn’t tell someone from another legitimate Chen lineage that they’re doing it wrong just because their curriculum is different from mine.

What I can say is that Laojia first made much more sense for me personally. Xinjia demands things I wouldn’t even have recognized as requirements when I was new. It’s difficult to refine a tiny spiral when you can’t maintain the large one. It’s difficult to issue repeated fajin when an ordinary weight shift still pulls you off balance. It’s difficult to work with subtle chest-and-waist folding while most of your attention is still being used to remember what posture comes next.

Learning progressively saved me a lot of frustration.

How Long Should You Practice Laojia Before Xinjia?

I don’t think there’s a responsible answer like “exactly three years.” Two students can train for three years and accumulate completely different amounts of practice. Someone training for two hours most days isn’t really on the same timetable as somebody who attends class twice a month and rarely practices at home.

That’s why I prefer thinking in terms of milestones instead of calendar years. Before putting serious energy into Xinjia, I’d want Laojia to feel familiar enough that remembering the choreography no longer consumes most of my attention. Weight shifting should be stable. The waist and kua should actually participate instead of merely following the hands. Silk reeling should begin to feel like a whole-body process, and at least some fajin should be coming through the body rather than being manufactured by the shoulder.

For many ordinary students, reaching that point really can take several years. That isn’t bad news. Traditional Tai Chi isn’t software where you need to worry because you’re still running last year’s version. There’s no prize for installing Xinjia early.

Laojia and Xinjia Aren’t Different Martial Arts

After talking about all these differences, it would be easy to make Xinjia sound almost like another system. That isn’t how I see it. Chen Xiaoxing summarized the relationship well when he said, “The Old and New Frames should not be viewed as different entities.”

The fundamental requirements remain connected. Both need roundness, continuity, coordinated upper and lower body movement, the relationship between hard and soft, and the ability to change between slow and fast. Xinjia doesn’t throw away Laojia’s principles and replace them with some secret advanced set of principles. It asks you to express many of the same ideas through smaller, denser, and often more physically demanding movements.

This is why someone with very good Laojia can be far more skilled than someone who has memorized both Laojia and Xinjia. Forms aren’t martial arts merit badges. Knowing more choreography doesn’t automatically mean having more gongfu.

How Many People Actually Practice Laojia or Xinjia?

This is one of those questions where I’d rather say we don’t know than invent an impressive number. Modern estimates have placed the total number of Tai Chi practitioners worldwide at more than 300 million, but there isn’t a credible worldwide census separating Chen from Yang, much less Laojia practitioners from Xinjia practitioners.

We do have smaller data points. A 2024 international survey of 226 Chinese martial arts practitioners found that 16.4% selected Chen-style Tai Chi, compared with 33.6% for Yang Style. That doesn’t represent global market share, but it does give some evidence for something most Tai Chi practitioners already notice: Yang Style has a much larger international footprint than Chen.

Within Chen Style itself, reliable Laojia-versus-Xinjia participation numbers simply aren’t available. Chen Xiaowang said in a 2013 interview that roughly 300,000 people had joined his worldwide Tai Chi association and that he had personally trained around 30,000, but those figures don’t tell us how many practiced Laojia, Xinjia, weapons, shorter forms, or several of them together.

My practical impression is that Laojia has considerably broader exposure in Chenjiagou-derived schools because it’s so commonly used as the foundation form, but I wouldn’t turn that observation into a percentage without reliable evidence.

The Biggest Xinjia Mistake I See Is Trying to Look Advanced

One thing I’ve learned from practicing Xinjia is that advanced-looking movement can be surprisingly easy to imitate badly. Small spirals, low postures, dramatic waist folding, and fajin look impressive, particularly on video. That creates a temptation to emphasize everything until the form has more movement but less connection.

The hips start wiggling, the chest folds too much, the wrists spin, and every fajin turns into a full-body performance. It may look energetic, but the center isn’t necessarily controlling anything. That’s why warnings from experienced Chen teachers about exaggerated spiraling make sense to me. The smaller circles in Xinjia are actually harder to execute correctly, and trying too hard to make them visible can disconnect the limbs from the waist.

The longer I practice, the less impressed I become by how complicated something looks. I’m much more interested in whether the movement arrives from the ground, passes through the body, and comes out without a lot of unnecessary effort.

So Is Xinjia More Advanced Than Laojia?

In the way I practice, yes, I regard Xinjia as the more advanced form. It asks for more developed silk-reeling skill, lower and more compact body work, stronger control through the waist and dantian, more frequent explosive power, more qinna expression, and better coordination of smaller circles.

But I’d put an asterisk next to the word “advanced.” Historically and across different Chen lineages, Xinjia isn’t universally treated as Level Two after Laojia. Some Beijing traditions begin with New Frame. Chen Xiaoxing himself described both as valid foundation systems while explaining why Chenjiagou generally starts students with Laojia.

The practical explanation makes the most sense to me. Laojia is steadier and gives you more room to understand the underlying principles, while the smaller spirals and denser body changes in Xinjia are harder to perform well. Laojia taught me the road. Xinjia made me start noticing everything happening underneath the pavement.

Which One Should a Beginner Learn First?

For someone approaching Chen Style without an established lineage telling them otherwise, I’d still recommend Laojia first. The reason isn’t that beginners are incapable of Xinjia. Laojia simply gives you more room to build many of the things Xinjia eventually demands.

You can work in a higher stance while the legs develop. You can learn larger spirals before shrinking them. You can understand softness before trying to release repeated power from it, and you can learn the route of the form without having to perform every smaller internal detail at the same time.

Once those things become more natural, Xinjia becomes much more interesting because you’re not just copying complexity from the outside. If you’ve already practiced Laojia for years, Xinjia can also be wonderfully humbling. Movements you thought you understood suddenly contain another layer. The waist has more work to do, the hands become less independent, the spirals get tighter, and the fajin exposes whether your lower and upper body are really connected.

What Practicing Both Has Taught Me

Laojia and Xinjia have given me very different lessons. Laojia taught me to slow down enough to build something. It let me develop structure, learn the large movements, strengthen the legs gradually, and begin understanding how silk-reeling mechanics connect one part of the body to another.

Xinjia taught me that having a foundation and being able to use it under harder conditions are two different things. Lower stances showed where my legs were weak. Smaller spirals showed where my arms were working independently. More frequent fajin exposed tension I didn’t notice while moving slowly, and the more complicated waist and dantian work made me realize that some movements I had considered finished were still pretty rough.

That’s probably why I wouldn’t want to skip Laojia even if someone offered me a shortcut directly into Xinjia. The shortcut might save some time memorizing one form, but it could cost years trying to understand what the second form was actually asking me to do. Traditional martial arts already have enough shortcuts. Most of them seem to lead in circles.

Final Thoughts: The Real Difference Between Laojia and Xinjia

If you want the shortest answer, Laojia is generally the steadier and more approachable expression of the Chen large-frame system, while Xinjia makes smaller spirals, waist and dantian rotation, chest-and-waist folding, qinna, lower compact movement, and explosive fajin much more prominent. Common counts give Laojia Yilu around 74 postures and Xinjia Yilu around 83, although counting varies by lineage.

But the numbers aren’t really the difference that matters. In my practice, Laojia gave me room to learn. I could stand somewhat higher, move more slowly, feel the larger spirals, and develop power gradually. Xinjia demanded much more. The stance wanted to drop, the spirals became tighter, the waist had more complicated work to do, and fajin appeared often enough that there wasn’t much room to hide poor coordination.

That’s why I still think of Laojia as the foundation and Xinjia as advanced work, while recognizing that not every Chen lineage teaches them in that order. I wouldn’t hurry from one to the other. In fact, practicing Xinjia has often made me want to go back and practice Laojia more carefully.

That may be the most useful thing Xinjia has taught me. The advanced form doesn’t make the basic form obsolete. It shows you how much of the basic form you still haven’t understood.